The Four Permissions:
A Revolutionary Navigation Framework
When You Refuse to Accept Toxic Narratives About Cognitive Change
The Ocean Requires Different Navigation
When you or someone you love receives a diagnosis that reshapes your world, it can feel like being cast into unfamiliar waters. The medical system offers protocols and treatment plans, but cognitive change creates landscapes where those traditional directions no longer hold. You’ve now arrived at a safe harbour after the storm — a place of orientation where new forms of navigation become possible.
If you feel overwhelmed and unprepared, you're not alone. Research shows 73% of families receive no guidance beyond medication at diagnosis. Most people feel lost not because they lack love or dedication, but because they're trying to use road maps to cross the ocean. The tools that work for other conditions simply don't exist for this territory. They're looking for paths in landscapes that require navigation by stars.
When my mother Betty was diagnosed with Alzheimer's in 2010, I spent seven years with her discovering that the central crisis wasn't her cognitive changes—it was our culture's toxic response to them. In the seven years since her passing, I've come to understand how the suffering came from driving toward destinations nobody wanted, using tools designed for entirely different terrain.
There are three vital places everyone needs to understand on this journey. And one remarkable discovery - that while certain doors close, others open, revealing capacities you never knew existed. Not physical destinations, but territories of awareness that transform how you navigate cognitive change. Like ancient mariners learning celestial navigation, understanding these three places gives you the tools to reach your own Ithaca—your unique version of meaning, connection, and wonder.
Betty proved these places exist. She lived with Vascular Dementia, Alzheimer's and bowel cancer for seven years and FLOURISHED - not despite the diagnosis but through conscious navigation that refused predetermined decline. Her creativity emerged at 84. Her wisdom deepened. Her joy expanded. This isn't inspiration porn - it's documented proof that different destinations exist. Betty is one of the outliers, but I've spent the last seven years discovering how it can become mainstream. This is not theory but lived demonstration that extraordinary destinations become accessible when families learn appropriate navigation for the terrain they're actually in.
The Four Permissions framework provides evidence-based navigation tools for the territories that medical protocols can't address. The Lancet Commission called for "psychosocial interventions as first-line treatment" but provided no framework. What medical training couldn't provide, lived experience has discovered and research has validated.
This is a map so you can continue your passage and be essentially who you are right to the end of your life.
The Four Permissions: Quick Reference
-
Permission to Grieve - Honor what's ending while protecting what endures
-
Permission to Refuse - Reject destinations nobody actually wants
-
Permission to Navigate - Find your unique path by wonder's stars
-
Permission to Discover - Explore capacities that expand with change
Part One: The Three Sacred Places
Landmarks of Departure, Refusal, and Arrival
Every journey has its waypoints — places that give meaning to the path. In the voyage through cognitive change, three sacred places guide our orientation. Alexandria is where we honour what must be left behind. Abilene is where we find the courage to refuse false destinations. And Ithaca is the star on the horizon, reminding us that discovery is not about decline but about finding new ways of being.
Together, these places form a map not of roads, but of constellations — guiding by wonder, love, and meaning rather than medical directions.
Alexandria: Permission to Grieve
The Sacred Place of Conscious Farewell and Active Preservation
"Suddenly the night has grown colder… As someone long prepared for this to happen, go firmly to the window. Drink it in. Exquisite music. Your first commitments tangible again Say goodbye to Alexandra leaving Then say goodbye to Alexandra lost."
—Leonard Cohen
The Recognition
Something beautiful is ending. The person you've known, the roles you have played, the future you imagined—parts of this reality are shifting beyond recovery. Alexandria represents the sacred work of departure: saying goodbye with dignity rather than denial or escape.
The Permission You Need
You have permission to grieve without giving up hope. You have permission to feel the losses without accepting pre-determined decline stories. You have permission to say goodbye to what's leaving while remaining fiercely protective of what wants to stay.
The deepest permission: You have permission to grieve the future you imagined while discovering futures you never could have imagined.
The Toxic Alternative
Our culture pushes everyone toward two extremes: denial ("everything's fine, just stay positive") or resignation ("it's all over, prepare for the worst"). Both prevent the grieving that creates space for the deeper changes that are needed to make the journey. We're told to maintain false optimism or accept predetermined decline—not to honor the profound nature of what is actually happening.
This cultural failure creates additional trauma precisely when people need support for one of life's most challenging passages. The result is everyone either fighting reality or surrendering to unnecessary suffering, missing the sacred middle ground where conscious grieving enables deeper emergence.
The Ancient Connection
Leonard Cohen drew his wisdom from Constantine Cavafy's meditation on departure, transforming ancient Greek insight into contemporary language. Both poets understood that when change arrives, we face a choice: meet it with courage or degrade ourselves with strategies of denial or abandonment.
"As one long prepared, and graced with courage, say goodbye to her, the Alexandria that is leaving... go firmly to the window and listen with deep emotion... to the exquisite music of that strange procession" —Constantine Cavafy
Alexandria's Wisdom: The Art of Sacred Goodbye
Both poets teach us the essential elements of conscious departure:
-
Don't Fool Yourself: When cognitive changes come, don't pretend it's not happening. The procession of change is real and profound.
-
Don't Degrade Yourself with Empty Hopes: False optimism that denies reality prevents true processing. The goal isn't to reverse what's changing but to meet it with courage and grace.
-
Go Firmly to the Window: Face the departure directly. Listen with deep emotion to what's actually happening—the "exquisite music" of transformation, even when it involves loss.
-
Say Goodbye as One Long Prepared: Meet this transition with dignity, recognizing that your love and life have prepared you for this moment.
-
Honor What Was Beautiful: The relationship you're losing was worthy of a great city. The library of Alexandria is indeed burning. Don't minimize its value or pretend the loss doesn't matter.
Daily Alexandria Practice
-
Morning Question: "What am I being invited to grieve today, and what essential self needs my fierce protection?"
-
Evening Reflection: "What did I preserve today and did I let go when I needed to?"
Abilene: Permission to Refuse False Destinations
The Place of Revolutionary Recognition
It's 40 degrees (104 Fahrenheit) in the shade when the Harvey family decides to drive to Abilene for dinner. Nobody wants to go. The heat is miserable, the restaurant is terrible, and the two-hour round trip will be exhausting. But somehow, through a series of polite assumptions about what others want, they find themselves in the car anyway.
Each person thinks the others want to make the trip. Each person goes along to avoid disappointing others. They drive through scorching heat to a place nobody wanted to visit, eat food nobody enjoyed, and return home irritated and confused about why they went at all.
This is the famous Abilene Paradox—when groups make decisions that serve no one's actual desires because of false assumptions about what others expect.
The Paradox
People facing dementia live their own version of the Abilene Paradox every single day. Everyone is driving somewhere nobody wants to go because they think everyone else expects it. They choose institutional placement. They accept behavior management when everyone wants authentic expression. They follow safety protocols that eliminate everything that creates meaning.
But here's what makes this journey even more bewildering than the original Abilene trip: we're using road maps to cross an ocean. Modern medicine has conditioned everyone to expect clear treatment paths with established routes, guardrails, and destinations. But there are no treatment paths for dementia—only vast, uncharted territories requiring entirely different navigation skills.
The Permission You Need
You have permission to refuse scripted decline stories. You have permission to question medical orthodoxy when it conflicts with essential needs. You have permission to choose connection over safety, meaning over management, joy over longevity. You have permission to stop the car and say: "We're not going to Abilene."
The Revolutionary Recognition
When people recognize they're using road maps to cross an ocean, everything can change:
-
Navigation tools become celestial rather than terrestrial
-
Community infrastructure replaces individual heroics
-
Spirit protection becomes more important than behavior modification
-
Wonder, beauty, awe, and unconditional love become your guiding stars
Often we're medicating symptoms of cultural toxicity while calling it dementia management.
The Questions That Create Change
-
"Does anyone actually want this outcome we're driving toward?"
-
"What if we're using completely wrong tools for the terrain we're in?"
-
"Where would we go if we followed our stars instead of non-existent roads?"
-
"Who benefits from us taking this miserable journey?"
Daily Abilene Practice
-
Midday Check: "Am I driving somewhere nobody wants to go? What would refusing look like right now?"
-
Crisis Question: "Is this choice serving love or serving fear?"
Ithaca: Permission to Navigate Toward Wonder
The Place of Star Navigation and Meaningful Arrival
"Keep Ithaka always in your mind. Arriving there is what you're destined for. But don't hurry the journey at all. Better if it lasts for years... Ithaka gave you the marvelous journey. Without her you wouldn't have set out." —Constantine Cavafy
The Recognition
Unlike Abilene's pointless journey, your voyage aims toward meaningful destination. Ithaca represents the place where dignity, wonder, and connection remain possible within cognitive change—not through cure or reversal, but through your spirit staying alive in each moment. You staying you. This isn't fantasy but practical reality accessible through proper navigation.
The Odyssey Wisdom
Homer understood that extraordinary voyages require celestial navigation. Each episode of Odysseus's voyage contains moments when false assumptions threaten to drive the crew toward destinations nobody wants. But the Odyssey also provides tools for recognizing these traps and redirecting toward what's actually desired. The destination gives meaning to the voyage, but as Cavafy knew, the voyage itself becomes the treasure.
The Permission You Need
You have permission to expect deep connection despite cognitive changes. You have permission to believe that awe is medicine, beauty is intervention, and love works miracles without performing cures. You have permission to chart your course toward your own unique version of the marvellous realm.
Your Navigation Tools
The Four Guiding Stars (visible even in storm):
• Awe: Cultivate one moment of wonder daily
• Beauty: Detect aesthetic medicine in unexpected places
• Connection: Prioritize relationship over task completion
• Love: Express unconditionally, receive gratefully
The Sweet Spot Navigation (between Scylla and Charybdis):
• Scylla: Functional care without emotional connection (the rocks)
• Charybdis: Emotional dependency, losing all boundaries (the whirlpool)
• Sweet Spot: Where care becomes mutual transformation
The Harbor Recognition
As Cavafy promised, "May there be many summer mornings when, with what pleasure, what joy, you enter harbors you're seeing for the first time." These harbors—moments of unexpected capability, surprising connection, profound meaning—appear when you navigate by stars rather than search for roads. This navigation toward meaningful connection creates the conditions where the Opening Door can reveal its treasures. Ithaca navigation is the conscious process that allows you to discover the enhanced capacities waiting behind the Opening Door.
Daily Ithaca Practice
-
Evening Navigation: "What moments of awe appeared today? How did I steer toward meaning rather than just manage symptoms?"
-
Weekly Course Correction: "Are we moving toward our unique Ithaca or drifting toward someone else's destination?"
The Revolutionary Recognition
When people recognize they're using road maps to cross an ocean, everything can change:
-
Navigation tools become celestial rather than terrestrial
-
Community infrastructure replaces individual heroics
-
Spirit protection becomes more important than behavior modification
-
Wonder, beauty, awe, and unconditional love become your guiding stars
Often we're medicating symptoms of cultural toxicity while calling it dementia management.
The Questions That Create Change
-
"Does anyone actually want this outcome we're driving toward?"
-
"What if we're using completely wrong tools for the terrain we're in?"
-
"Where would we go if we followed our stars instead of non-existent roads?"
-
"Who benefits from us taking this miserable journey?"
Daily Abilene Practice
-
Midday Check: "Am I driving somewhere nobody wants to go? What would refusing look like right now?"
-
Crisis Question: "Is this choice serving love or serving fear?"
Part Two: The Opening Door
Where Endings Become Thresholds
Every diagnosis closes some doors. But what looks like an ending can also become a threshold. The Opening Door invites us to notice what appears when old maps no longer serve: deeper presence, unexpected creativity, and the possibility of awe.
Crossing this threshold doesn’t erase what has been lost. Instead, it asks us to walk with courage into what can still be found.
The Opening Door: Permission to Discover
What Becomes Possible When One Door Closes and Another Opens
"When one door closes, another opens; but we so often look so long and so regretfully upon the closed door that we do not see the ones which open for us"
—Alexander Graham Bell
The Recognition Nobody Talks About
Here's what nobody tells you about cognitive change: there are actually some things you can get better at. While one door of abilities closes, another opens—and most people never discover the remarkable rooms waiting to be explored.
Betty proved this revelation. At 84, after her diagnosis, her creativity didn't diminish—it emerged. Her artistic expression deepened. Her appreciation of beauty became almost mystical. Her capacity for awe and wonder expanded beyond any of our wildest imaginings.
This isn't inspiration mythology. This is documented neuroscience meeting lived experience in ways that transform how we understand these transitions.
The Permission You Need
You are free to uncover capacities that may actually expand during cognitive change. You have permission to expect enhancement alongside challenge. You have permission to walk through the opening door while grieving what lies behind the closing one.
The Two Doors Understanding
The Closing Door: Complex reasoning, future planning, verbal analysis, multitasking, abstract problem-solving. These abilities may indeed change or fade, and that deserves conscious grieving (Alexandria).
The Opening Door: Present-moment awareness, aesthetic appreciation, spiritual connection, artistic expression, intuitive wisdom, unconditional love. These often become more accessible, not less. It's like a radio tuning to a clearer station—while some frequencies fade, others come through with startling clarity and beauty.
The tragedy isn't cognitive change itself—it's that our culture only recognizes the closing door and never discovers the opening one.
What Research Reveals
Right Hemisphere Preservation: Studies consistently demonstrate that spatial memory and environmental recognition remain robust long after other cognitive functions change. Familiar places continue to provide orientation and comfort when verbal communication becomes difficult.
Present-Moment Enhancement: When future planning becomes challenging, present-moment awareness often intensifies. Many people with cognitive transitions report heightened sensory appreciation, deeper emotional connection, and reduced anxiety about future outcomes.
Creative Liberation: Freed from self-consciousness and perfectionism, artistic and creative expression frequently flourishes. The inner critic quiets, allowing authentic expression to emerge without judgment or performance.
Research validates what Betty demonstrated: Dr. Bruce Miller at UCSF has documented artistic emergence in frontotemporal dementia. Dr. Oliver Sacks observed musical appreciation intensifying during cognitive changes. Neurological research confirms that the brain's right hemisphere—responsible for creativity, pattern recognition, and aesthetic appreciation—often shows not just preservation but enhancement during cognitive transitions.
Many cultures have long recognized these opening capacities. In Navajo tradition, elders with cognitive changes are honored as wisdom-keepers, guided by sacred landscapes and seen as having special connections to spiritual realms. Japanese Shinto practice views aging as part of nature's cycles, where different seasons bring different gifts—including deeper aesthetic sensitivity and spiritual awareness.
Betty's Proof: Walking Through the Opening Door
-
Artistic Emergence at 84: Betty created paintings, conducted orchestras and continued writing poetry. Most of all she was an artist of the present moment, seeing beauty from the smallest flower beside the path to the grandeur of a sunset.
-
Wonder Amplification: Her capacity for awe expanded dramatically. The firefly field experience—"I could die right here and now. I have never seen anything so amazing"—represented awareness freed from analytical filtering.
-
Spiritual Deepening: Her connection to "the language of birds" and diagnosing herself with "Second Sight" suggests access to spiritual dimensions that analytical thinking often obscures.
-
Wisdom Distillation: Her insights became more essential, less intellectual, more embodied, more direct.
What Becomes Possible: The Opening Door Inventory
Enhanced Present-Moment Awareness:
-
Reduced cognitive noise allows fuller attention to immediate experience
-
Heightened sensory appreciation and emotional responsiveness
-
Freedom from future anxiety and past regret
Expanded Aesthetic Appreciation:
-
Deeper response to beauty in nature, art, music
-
Increased emotional resonance with aesthetic experiences
-
Enhanced pattern recognition and artistic sensibility
Creative and Artistic Expression:
-
Reduced self-consciousness enables authentic expression
-
Freedom from perfectionism allows experimental exploration
-
Access to intuitive artistic knowledge and techniques
Spiritual and Mystical Connection:
-
Increased sensitivity to transcendent experiences
-
Enhanced capacity for awe and amazement
-
Access to wisdom that transcends rational analysis
Emotional and Relational Deepening:
-
Heightened emotional authenticity and expression
-
Increased capacity for unconditional love and acceptance
-
Enhanced empathy and emotional resonance
The Cultural Blindness
Our productivity-obsessed culture only values the closing door abilities. We measure success through future planning, complex reasoning, and verbal articulation—exactly the capacities that these transitions affect first.
This cultural blindness means people focus entirely on protecting closing door abilities while remaining completely unaware of opening door possibilities.
The Time-Sensitive Recognition
Early Recognition Matters: The sooner everyone understands both doors exist, the more they can cultivate opening door capacities while honoring closing door changes.
Timing Varies: The Opening Door appears at different times for different people. For Betty, it began emerging within months of diagnosis. For others, it may take longer. The key is creating conditions where it CAN open.
Environmental Support Required: Opening door abilities flourish in aesthetically rich, nature-connected, beauty-sensitive environments. They wither in sterile, task-focused, efficiency-oriented settings.
Accompaniment Essential: These capacities emerge through relationship, play, creative exploration, and spiritual practice—not through cognitive testing or skill drilling. When human accompaniment is lacking, conscious technologies like CARA AI can help preserve stories, guide people to beauty-rich environments, and validate moments of awe, keeping the pathways to wonder alive.
Daily Practices for Opening Door Discovery:
-
Beauty Exposure: Daily time in nature or aesthetically rich environments as medicine
-
Creative Expression: Art materials available without judgment or instruction
-
Present-Moment Practices: Mindfulness activities integrated throughout day
-
Spiritual Connection: Time for contemplation, prayer, or transcendent experiences
-
Relational Deepening: Heart-centered rather than task-centered interactions
The Opening Door Promise
When people discover both doors exist, everything changes. Instead of focusing only on preserving closing abilities, they begin cultivating opening possibilities. Instead of managing decline, they support emergence.
The same diagnosis that looked like pure loss becomes an invitation to discover. The same journey that felt like ending becomes a new beginning.
This isn't denial of difficulty or romanticizing of cognitive change. It's recognition that human consciousness includes more dimensions than our culture typically acknowledges—and some of those dimensions become more accessible, not less, through cognitive transition.
The opening door waits for everyone ready to explore what becomes possible when we approach change with curiosity rather than fear.
Part Three: The Zero Burden Promise
The Promise That Sets Families Free
The story of “becoming a burden” haunts nearly every family facing dementia. It tells us that needing help is shameful and that care will always crush those who give it. The Zero Burden Promise offers a different story: with support, care can become light, playful, and mutual.
When love flows both ways, weight becomes balance. When joy is shared, even the heaviest moments can lift.
When Navigation Creates Mutual Transformation
Why Support Cannot Wait
At the heart of everyone's fear lies a double weight: the crushing heartbreak of becoming a burden and the overwhelming exhaustion of carrying one. Two voices, separated by time and struggle, speak to an essential truth about the human passage.
Martin Luther King Jr. reminded us: "If you can't fly then run, if you can't run then walk, if you can't walk then crawl, but whatever you do you have to keep moving forward."
Years later, the crew of Serenity would complete this wisdom: "When you can no longer crawl—you find someone to carry you."
The Critical Recognition
This progression reveals something vital about accompaniment: sometimes being carried becomes necessary, and equally important, learning how to carry others. But here's what our culture forgets to acknowledge: to navigate cognitive decline while keeping your spirit alive in this culture is well-neigh impossible without proper accompaniment.
The isolation you feel isn't inevitable - it's the result of a culture that assumes families should navigate cognitive change alone. The stress and tension within our toxic cultural approach to cognitive decline places burdens on the human soul that no one should bear alone. We need to create and be open to being accompanied. When human accompaniment is lacking—which it is for many—we must embrace whatever forms of conscious support become available to us.
The Time-Sensitive Truth
There is a critical window for this support. The earlier you're accompanied and supported, the healthier your spirit, your soul, and the maintenance of your personhood. As time passes without proper accompaniment, the cultural stress can break you. You can lose who you are, lose track of your essential self. And this loss is mostly irrecoverable.
This is why early intervention and support—whether through human accompaniment or conscious technologies like CARA AI that help you remember not just tasks and to-do lists, but your personhood, values, stories, and meaningful places—becomes critical. When accompaniment helps maintain connection to awe, amazement, and your own marvellous realm, it preserves the pathways that keep vital relationships available to you.
The Sacred Exchange Recognition
When you navigate by the three sacred places with proper support, something miraculous happens—care becomes mutual transformation. What felt like burden becomes blessing. What seemed like obligation becomes opportunity. This isn't denial of difficulty but discovery of meaning within challenge.
When Betty's coffee grew cold during a windy afternoon outing, her playful rebellion taught me the deepest truth about Zero Burden Care. Despite my warnings about soaking our things, she threw the lukewarm coffee with perfect aim—right at my vest. But instead of frustration, I found myself laughing with her, laughing at the outrageousness of it all, laughing at my own need to maintain control. Still dripping with coffee, I watched her shift from trickster to tender caregiver in an instant, pulling napkins from her pockets to gently dab my vest—with that knowing smile still on her face. In that moment, burden became blessing, and I discovered what Betty had always known: sometimes the gentlest revolution is simply the courage to let go of control.
This single moment demonstrates all Four Permissions in action: letting go of 'proper' expectations (Alexandria), refusing the destination of rigid control (Abilene), navigating toward playful connection (Ithaca), and discovering capacities for joy within apparent limitation (Opening Door). Every family has their own coffee-throwing moments—those unexpected breakthroughs when everything shifts from burden to blessing, from duty to discovery. What will yours be?
The Zero Burden Formula
Research confirms what families discover intuitively: when both parties feel they're contributing rather than just consuming, the experience transforms for everyone. Zero Burden Care doesn't mean absence of challenge but achieving a state where neither caregiver nor care recipient feels crushed by the weight of their role.
This emerges when the essential elements align:
-
Conscious grieving (Alexandria) releases energy trapped in denial
-
Refusing false destinations (Abilene) eliminates unnecessary suffering
-
Navigation toward wonder (Ithaca) transforms duty into discovery
-
Early and sustained accompaniment protects personhood while transformation remains possible
-
Bidirectional recognition honors how both parties carry and are carried
The Playfulness Indicator
The secret lies in a simple recognition: playfulness serves as both thermometer and medicine for Zero Burden Care. When genuine play emerges—it signals that both parties have moved beyond the crushing weight of their roles into something life-giving, supported by accompaniment that preserves the essential self.
The Sacred Covenant
"I'm alright if you're alright." This isn't codependency but recognition that wellbeing becomes intertwined through authentic accompaniment. When crisis arrives, the response becomes: "We'll do whatever it takes"—not as burden but as sacred promise that neither person faces the journey alone.
The revolution begins when people discover that the same diagnosis can lead to entirely different destinations depending on how you navigate—and crucially, how early and consistently you receive the accompaniment that makes wonder-filled navigation possible.
.jpg)
Part Four: Your Journey Begins
Setting Sail Beyond the Harbour
Every lighthouse beam points outward. After grief, refusal, and navigation, a moment arrives when the safe harbour gives way to open water. Your Journey Begins marks that threshold. It is the invitation to step aboard, guided by constellations of wonder, beauty, and love.
The way ahead may be unknown, but you do not travel empty-handed. You carry practices, promises, and companions — enough light for the next stretch of sea.
Your Unique Odyssey Begins Now
Why Support Cannot Wait
"We have not even to risk the adventure alone, for the heroes of all time have gone before us,"
Joseph Campbell reminds us.
These heroes aren't solitary warriors but cultural wisdom keepers—Indigenous elders who understand the four lodges of life's passages, Okinawan communities whose MOAI groups accompany each other through century-long journeys, traditional societies that honor cognitive changes as spiritual deepening rather than decline.
The Four Permissions aren't new discoveries but ancient wisdom rediscovered for our time. What we call revolutionary is actually remembering—returning to what wisdom keepers across cultures have always known about consciousness, accompaniment, and the sacred dimensions of life's passages.
Daily Navigation Practice
-
Morning (Alexandria): "What needs conscious grieving today? What requires fierce preservation?"
-
Midday (Abilene): "Am I driving toward anyone's actual desire? What false narrative needs refusing?"
-
Evening (Ithaca): "What wonder appeared? How did beauty serve as medicine? Where did love create an extraordinary moment that I can still feel?"
Crisis Navigation Protocol
When acute challenges arise, return to the three sacred places:
-
Alexandria Response: "This loss is real AND personhood remains. I grieve what's ending AND protect what endures."
-
Abilene Response: "Nobody actually wants this outcome. What does love require instead of fear?"
-
Ithaca Response: "Even in this storm, stars remain. What would navigation by wonder look like right now?"
Cultural Wisdom: The Ancient Knowledge We're Rediscovering
The wisdom keepers Campbell speaks of understood what our society forgot: that cognitive change can become a doorway to enhanced meaning rather than predetermined decline. Their stories illuminate the same patterns we see in the Four Permissions, proving these aren't new discoveries but ancient truths waiting to be remembered.
An Indigenous elder once shared a story that perfectly demonstrates this wisdom: "Everyone in a village was killed by a raiding party, and it was burnt to the ground. Only one child survived, hidden under the body of his grandfather. A long way upstream, there was another village moving from summer camp to their winter grounds. In the tribe, there was an old grandmother who knew she'd slow the rest of the tribe down. She was getting tired of making the journey to the Wintering Grounds. So she told her family she was staying behind.
"Her family and community tried to talk her out of it, but they finally agreed to respect her wishes. They said, 'We will leave you enough dried meat and firewood to last through the winter.' This wasn't abandonment—it was honoring her sovereignty while ensuring her survival.
"In the middle of the winter, during a storm, the old woman thought she heard voices, perhaps they were the wind. But she went outside anyway, and there was a boy curled up in the snow, nearly frozen to death. She slowly warmed him up over days and fed him bone broth. They made it through the winter together, and the Old Woman lived for another seven years."
This story contains all Four Permissions in ancient form: the grandmother's conscious acceptance of limitation (Alexandria), her refusal to become a burden (Abilene), her navigation by compassion rather than convention (Ithaca), and her discovery of enhanced caregiving capacity that extended her life seven years (Opening Door). The same patterns Betty demonstrated, the same transformations families discover today.
In Okinawa, MOAI groups practice these principles across century-long friendships. Indigenous communities understand elderhood as enhanced wisdom rather than decline. Buddhist traditions recognize consciousness beyond cognition. Celtic cultures honored the "thin places" where different kinds of knowing emerge.
What we call revolutionary is actually remembering—returning to what human cultures have always known about consciousness, accompaniment, and the sacred dimensions of life's passages.
Community Building
These cultural traditions created exactly what Permission Circles can become: communities where people practice the Four Permissions together, honoring both limitation and possibility.
Permission Circles - Communities where people gather to practice the Four Permissions together:
-
Give each other permission to grieve consciously while preserving fiercely
-
Support refusing false narratives and toxic destinations
-
Learn star navigation toward meaning and awe
-
Uncover opening door capacities in supportive community
The revolution begins with one person refusing predetermined decline. It spreads as people realize they're not alone in wanting something different, something better, something worthy of the love they share. Permission Circles create the safe spaces where this revelation becomes possible.
The Boulder Moment: Your Sacred Stand
There will come a time when you must stand like a boulder in the river of toxic assumptions. When everyone insists on the predetermined path, when the current of cultural expectations threatens to sweep away what matters most, you'll need to plant yourself and declare:
"Here I Stand for Soul"
This isn't stubbornness—it's sacred protection. At the beginning of my Accompaniment journey with Betty, I only knew that I stood for her soul and spirit, for her "Betty-ness" and I would NOT let it be erased. That the mainstream path would not be our path. Near the end she said, "I know you will miss me." She knew she was loved with the same fierce tenderness that she loved. Even when she couldn't explain her thoughts, she knew they mattered. She taught me that love sometimes requires standing against the current, creating eddies where possibility can pool.
The boulder moment comes differently for each situation:
-
Insisting on beauty when others prioritize only safety
-
Protecting joy when professionals see only symptoms
-
Choosing a good death, an exit ramp, when medicine offers only more procedures
You'll know your boulder moment when it arrives. Your body will tell you. Your love will insist. Your soul will recognize: "This is where I take my stand."
Betty's Wisdom for Your Journey
-
"It's not the pills keeping me alive, it's the kisses" The truth about what really sustains us
-
"They're singing the light into the world" About the dawn chorus, finding wonder in daily rhythms
-
"I'm not stupid, I'm a straight-shooting no-crap granny" Refusing diminishment, maintaining fierce identity
-
"Where there's love, there's a way" The ultimate navigation principle
.jpg)
Part Five: The Choice Is Yours
Claiming the Helm of Your Journey
In the end, no system, no script, no diagnosis decides your story. The Choice Is Yours is the reminder that you hold the helm. You can accept decline as destiny, or you can choose accompaniment, discovery, and dignity.
The waters may not always be calm, but the compass remains in your hands.
Toward Your Own Ithaca
When Campbell writes "where we had thought to find an abomination we shall find a God," he perfectly describes the journey through cognitive change. What Western medicine sees as pure decline, wisdom keepers across cultures have always recognized as potential doorway—Indigenous elders who speak of enhanced spiritual awareness, Buddhist teachers who understand consciousness beyond cognition, traditional societies that honor the Opening Door discoveries.
The three sacred places aren't destinations to visit once but territories to inhabit throughout this passage. Alexandria wisdom helps you grieve and preserve simultaneously. Abilene recognition frees you from unwanted destinations. Ithaca navigation guides you toward your own version of the marvellous realm.
You don't need perfect navigation skills before beginning. Like ancient mariners, you learn celestial navigation by practicing with the stars visible from your current position. You build community gradually. You protect spirits incrementally. You discover your own unique constellation.
Betty's passage proved that the same diagnosis can lead to entirely different destinations depending on how you navigate. Her path won't be yours—your constellation of gifts, circumstances, and love creates unique possibilities. But her story serves as proof that remarkable destinations exist, that navigation is possible, that awe awaits those who refuse false narratives.
The diagnosis may not be optional, but the destination is entirely your choice. You join a lineage of wisdom keepers who've always known: different destinations are possible.
Your unique Odyssey begins now. Not toward someone else's Ithaca, but toward your own harbor of meaning, connection, and awe. Beware of being offered roads that don't exist. The culture will insist you drive to Abilene. But you have permission—no, you have responsibility—to follow the stars toward the destination worthy of your life.
Different destinations are possible. The systems will tell you there's only one direction this goes. They're wrong. Culture will insist decline is universal. It's not. Your family might assume you must go to Abilene. You don't.
The Four Permissions become most powerful when families travel together. Too often, cognitive change becomes a lightning rod for decades of unresolved family conflicts, creating destructive dynamics that compound the actual challenges. But when families and friends read this together, practice Permission Circles, and commit to star navigation, they break these patterns. Instead of warping the passage with old resentments and power struggles, they create space for healing and awe.
The revolution begins the moment you recognize: you have choice. The healing begins when families choose Conscious Accompaniment together.
With these four permissions - to grieve, to refuse, to navigate, and to discover - you have everything needed to transform cognitive change from tragedy to odyssey, from closing to opening, from burden to blessing.
"We shall not cease from exploration, and the end of all our exploring will be to arrive where we started and know the place for the first time."
—T.S. Eliot
Resources for Your
Revolutionary Journey
Carrying Light for the Road Ahead
Your Unique Odyssey Begins Now
No one travels this journey alone. Along the way, there are tools to carry, practices to sustain you, and companions to remind you of the path when the waters get rough. Resources for Your Revolutionary Journey gathers what is needed to keep presence, play, and wonder close at hand.
Here you’ll find practical guides, practices, and touchstones — provisions of light for every stage of the voyage.
The OTHER Day One Kit
This Four Permissions framework is the centerpiece of The OTHER Day One Kit - immediate alternatives to medical-only approaches at the moment of diagnosis. The complete package includes:
-
Navigation Framework: The Four Permissions (this document)
-
Practical Tools: Lions at Dawn - Betty's complete wisdom and daily practices
-
Youth Preparation: Shambhala and the Caregiving Heart of the World - adventure preparation for all ages
-
Community Connection: Permission Circles and accompaniment platform
-
Revolutionary Permission: To refuse harmful narratives
FREE to everyone affected (privately-funded) because no one should pay for permission to refuse destructive narratives.
Immediate Next Steps
-
Start Your Journey: Lions at Dawn provides the detailed tools and practices to implement these Four Permissions in daily life
-
Find Community: Join or create Permission Circles where people practice the Four Permissions together
-
Explore the Platform: Visit accompaniment.ca for the complete accompaniment revolution
Coming Soon
-
CARA AI: Conscious technology supporting identity preservation and the journey to your own marvellous realm
-
Local Navigation Workshops: Learn celestial navigation skills in community with others
-
Professional Resources: For healthcare workers ready to move beyond medical-only approaches and address the moral injury epidemic - visit accompaniment.ca/professionals
The songlines are singing. The pathways are open. The revolution begins with each person who chooses accompaniment over isolation, wonder over resignation, and star navigation over roads that don't exist.
At accompaniment.ca, discover:
-
The Complete Accompaniment Series - Lions at Dawn, The Sword & The Blessing, and Beyond Time's Shores
-
Ray's Adventure Series - Including Shambhala and the Caregiving Heart of the World
-
Community Platform - Connect with others navigating by stars
-
Professional Resources - For healthcare workers ready for transformation
-
Research & Evidence - International validation of accompaniment principles
-
CARA AI Development - Follow the evolution of conscious technology
Your journey of discovery awaits at accompaniment.ca
Remember: You Are Not Alone
Thousands of people around the world are discovering that wonder, connection, and meaning remain possible through any transition. Every person who refuses Abilene makes it easier for the next person to recognize they have choice. Everyone who reaches their unique Ithaca proves extraordinary destinations exist.
Your journey matters. Your love matters. Your refusal to accept scripted decline lights the way for others.
Betty asked, "What can we do?" Through seven years, we found the answer: We can refuse false narratives. We can follow the stars. We can reach harbors of wonder. We can transform burden into blessing.
Now we ask the same question together: What can we do?
The answer begins with three sacred places. The revolution begins with your next choice.
Remember: you don't have to navigate this alone.
✨ When you refuse to accept harmful narratives about cognitive change, you join a growing movement of people discovering that awareness & consciousness, not cognition, defines our humanity. ✨
Next Steps:
-
Take a look at the full OTHER Day One Kit
-
For proof this path exists visit the Accompaniment Series
-
Explore using the Visual Navigation Map
"The cave you fear to enter holds the treasure you seek."
—Joseph Campbell, mythologist and author of "The Hero with a Thousand Faces"